Saturday, 14 February 2009

Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008) *Second viewing

Today being Valentine's Day, I took my wonderful wife to see Vicky Cristina Barcelona at her request even though I saw this just a couple of weeks ago and rated it as a 7/10 film. On second viewing I think that's about fair- perhaps even a little on the stingy side. What stood out for me far more this time was the cynicism behind the film- every motivation and every relationship was treated as pretentious and false in its own way. As if Woody was simply sick of everything. I found it harder to engage with the protagonists- as it often is when a film is filled with spoilt people in big houses with no discernible source of income, but that's another matter- because I was more aware of the bitterness below the surface. I think that's a strength of the film, though, you can suspend disbelief and find yourself charmed by a film where for a short period of time people step out of their comfort zone and learn about themselves. A Spanish Roman Holiday, if you will. The easy flow and soundtrack-driven pace of the film allied to the use of a narrator (is there any better way to hint to an audience that it's okay to switch off their critical faculties?) aids this process tremendously and is probably the reason behind the film's relative success at the box office.

vcb1

On the other hand, you can view the film as a critique of pretensions and the way that the desire to appear as a tortured artist or as a fully 'together' and in control are simply two sides of the same coin. Interestingly, Vicky and Cristina are shown arriving and leaving via Barcelona Airport at the beginning and end of the movie via a split-screen in which their positions are swapped- as if to represent the way in which they have to some extent swapped what they want out of life with one another.

In fact the only character to come out of the film with his 'image' intact is Doug (played by Chris Messina who does this kind of dull straight-laced lawyer/broker type of role really well, as he showed in the risible Made of Honour). I was going to say 'come out sympathetically', but his character doesn't elicit sympathy- even though he's cuckolded throughout- simply because he's a bit of a dick. Nonetheless, he is the only main character to have been honest throughout the film. Even Javier Bardem's frank and forthright Juan Antonio is portrayed as playing out a pretence of honesty as Penélope Cruz's Maria Elena explains when massaging him to relieve a tension headache "Oh, to the world, he's carefree, nothing matters, life is short and with no purpose kind of thing. But all his fear just goes to his head". Interestingly, and I say this having seen the film twice, I'm certain that during the Spanish dialogue in that scene Cruz refers to Bardem's character as Javier and not Juan Antonio.

vcb2

And so, this is definitely a film I enjoyed seeing a second time. In fact, it had made me feel eager to re-engage with Woody Allen after sulking about his poor calibre output over the last twenty years and ignoring him for quite some time.

Friday, 13 February 2009

The Girl on a Motorcycle (1968)

This arrival of The Girl on a Motorcycle from LoveFilm couldn't have been neater. Consider that it is directed by Jack Cardiff, the genius cinematographer from Black Narcissus, who I have discussed in some depth recently, featuring Marianne Faithful (I've already discussed Anita Pallenberg the other infamous Stone-ette this week) and Nouvelle Vague icon Alain Delon ahead of my planned weekend of film Francophilia. How neat a bundle of coincidences could I want?

jack-cardiff-and-alain-delon
Jack Cardiff directs Alain Delon

Against that backdrop, though, the film could surely only disappoint. And it sadly does.

Often I will reflect that the more innovative and distinctive a film is, the more likely it is to be referenced, to influence and to be stolen from. And by that process the elements which inspire admiration- perhaps even adoration- come to seem mundane and commonplace. For the film fan trawling through the past, it is hard to fully appreciate the context in which a film was first seen. Coming just twenty years after the end of the second World War this film features Marianne Faithful passing a soldiers' graveyard and questioning the validity of the war and the sacrifices made- was this shocking iconoclasm or were many contemporaneous films exploring the same rueful territory?

I mention this because this film features extensive use of acid-coloured solarization, so much so that Jack Cardiff begins to irritate as if he were a child with a toy drumkit. Of course, the process also allows him to get away with longer and more graphic sequences of Faithful and Delon romping than would probably have been allowed otherwise. But I couldn't help thinking to myself "what's the point of going to all that trouble to show something that the viewer can't recognise anyway?". Whether these 'groovy' scenes achieved their aim in the 60s or not, I can't confirm- but they date the movie badly now and look clumsy and ineffective now.

And The Girl on a Motorcycle is really summed up by that. It is a film of worthy- though frankly ill-judged- intentions, attempting to record on film the thought and ambitions and streams of consciousness of a girl riding across continental Europe. Like a rites of passage road movie with one protagonist. Judged against such ambitious aims, it fails mightily. In fact, it is of no more merit than any number of cheap 60s exploitation B-movies. The plotline- the bit that isn't summed up by the title anyway- is told largely in flashback. Marianne Faithful's character Rebecca leaves her staid husband of a couple of weeks, the failing teacher Raymond (Roger Mutton- terrible actor but the wearer of a great quiff!) for Alain Delon's character Daniel, who she met and commenced an affair with in the run-up to the Wedding. Daniel is the only character in the piece of any substance whatsoever- maybe because Delon and Powell and Pressburger stalwart Marius Goring in a very minor role are the only actors of any merit on show. He is callous, manipulative and egotistical; though we discover that this bravado masks the deep pain of heartbreak.

The dialogue- which is mainly concerned with expressing Rebecca's inner thoughts and feelings- is stilted, obvious and typically vacuous Haight-Ashbury hippy nonsense- "not everyone who is dead has been buried"; "sometimes it's an instinct to fly. I'm not going to feel guilty"; "Rebellion's the only thing that keeps you alive"- that kind of bollocks. And only Delon's character- somewhat implausibly a university lecturer- has any lines which steer clear of cliché - during a seminar on, believe it or not, the morality of free love he opines "love without love, desire without love...so what is love? ... A blanket to cover all the dark emotions- desire, lust, a need to hurt, to be hurt". This isn't to say he escapes the scriptwriter's clunking prose throughout- his "Your body is like a violin in a velvet case" may well worst first line for any movie character ever.

girl-on-a-motorcycle

It is all so disappointing given the calibre of the people involved. There are blatant continuity errors, logical gaps (Daniel must be supernatural as he appears in a locked room at one point without any explanation how), wooden performances and lowest-common-denominator innuendo with the motorbike as a big cock. The Girl on a Motorcycle features a girl on a motorcycle on a low-loader- did no-one think that the lean and steering involved in cornering would make Faithful sat bolt upright as the bike takes a hairpin look pretty bloody stupid? Oh I despair! A French film by an English Director shot in Switzerland with the Frenchman Alain Delon as a German and the English Marianne Faithfull as a Swiss. This is all too much to bear.

I'm not generally in favour of remakes (not least because they keep that goofy slapheaded tit Nic Cage in work) but there is the kernel of a good idea in here being woefully badly executed. This could have been an exploration of freedom, of the feminist movement, of the futility of free love, of the futility of marriage, of existentialism, of expressionism, of any message the film-maker wants to say. The premise is a blank canvas. It could have been an artistic exploration; it could have been a beautifully simple road movie; it could have been any number of worthy and interesting things. But what it is, I'm afraid, is a fucking mess. If any film ever required a remake, this is it.

Devoid of subtlety, intrigue, wit or beauty, this is a very poor exploitation film. The only bit I liked at all was the sequence where Faithfull composed her farewell letters in a café, whilst Jack Cardiff filled the screen with faces of old men. It said nothing of interest, I just thought it looked nice. Oh, and I also liked the following exchange: "Love is a feeling" "so is toothache". 2/10

Tuesday, 10 February 2009

Wings of Desire / Der Himmel über Berlin (1987)

This film makes me feel like I am a popcorn-chomping, blockbuster addict. Not only do I not really 'get it', but I have now called it quits after making eight attempts to watch this over the course of a year and falling asleep every single time. I don't find the film boring at all- pretentious and self-consciously arty certainly, but not boring. I just find that the film's measured pace, somnambulistic progress through the streets of Berlin and snatches of conversation, music, private thoughts and dreams overlapping one another to be the perfect accompaniment to my drift toward sleep. That this style has been done to death since by arty pop-video makers doesn't help either.

From what I can gather it is a paean to Berlin and the people of Berlin as seen through the eyes of the angels who can "do no more than look, assemble, testify, preserve". There are a lot of references to children and the death of childhood- as if the people are the children and the angels are the adults watching over them. We also see a dying man recount the things he will miss just as the angels continue to ("blackened fingers from newspaper") again as if their existence is just an extension of our own lives. It's difficult to say having seen little more than a quarter of the film.

I like what I've seen of it- never much more than half an hour- and I'm intrigued to know what I'm missing. But I've cut my losses on this one. I'll try again on a summer afternoon when I'm wide awake but, for now, it scores a pretentious but beautiful 2/10.

Monday, 9 February 2009

Performance (1970)

For a long time during my teens I nurtured a probably unhealthy obsession with Brian Jones, the result of which has been a weaning-off process causing me to lock away my library of 'was Brian murdered?' books (of course he was) and avoid seeing this for the better part of two decades. Seeing Mick play Brian- to all intents and purposes- opposite the girl Keith stole from Brian was always going to be a bit weird. That the film is an almost total headfuck anyway, didn't help matters either.

Performance could be the ultimate Emperor's New Clothes movie. It could be a trippy, surreal but ultimately vacuous exercise in style over content from which unintended layers of meaning and allusion can be divined. It could be Chauncey Gardiner as a film, I'm absolutely aware of that. But I'm going to follow my instinct that it isn't. And, furthermore, even if it is I'm going to say that the allegorical nature of the film is no less valid if it is unintentional anyway. Why should it be?

The film opens in the brutal world of London gangsters with Chas (an utterly fantastic James Fox performance) and we get about half an hour of a fast-paced gritty crime drama in the vein of Get Carter or Villain but then suddenly lurches head-first into a psychedelic acid nightmare full of "long-hairs, druggers, beatniks and foreigners" blurring the lines between reality and surreality. In exactly the same way that Chas gets discombobulated by what he experiences, so does the viewer. The resulting confusion is deliberate as the two worlds are shown as more similar than they are different. The integration of the two worlds occurs by allusion during the magnificent 'Memo From Turner' sequence and then in actuality.

performance-still

The blending of identities and merging of entities is a recurrent theme. Chas and Turner, the hedonistic rock star in seclusion played by Mick Jagger, are increasingly shown as similar below their surface differences, they could almost be a masculine and feminine version of the same person. That duality is expressed in many ways; both literally (swapping styles of dress, superimposed faces etc) and by suggestion ("there's nothing wrong with me...I'm normal"). In fact the whole film investigates this identity confusion: there are mirrors and juxtaposed faces, picture disappear from frames between shots, sexual confusion, androgyny, altered perceptions, sanity and insanity, domination and submission, appearance changes and role swapping. Throughout the gangland scenes the phrase "it's not a takeover, it's a merger" is repeated and, in the end, we are presented with the surreal merging of people- Turner becomes Lucy, Chas becomes Turner, Turner becomes Chas. This bizarre distillation of Borgesian confusion is both challenging and illuminating.

performance

As a film, as a piece of entertainment, I would imagine that Performance might be considered a failure. There is no obvious hero or villain, no linear narrative, no clear outcome and the performances range from Fox's coruscating portrayal of Chas to Pallenberg's patchy and uneven Pherber. As a work of art, however, it is outstanding. And the soundtrack is incredible- 9/10.

And everyone should own a copy of Happy Mondays' Bummed which samples this film's dialogue heavily.

bummed

Sunday, 8 February 2009

The General (1927)

I was recently mesmerised by Buster Keaton's Our Hospitality and Sherlock Jr and was really looking forward to seeing the film that is generally regarded as his best and wasn't disappointed.

the-general-3

Buster's love of trains comes to the fore again here and they do allow plenty of scope for his breathtaking physical comedy. He really does these stunts as they look- it's literally inconceivable. The film takes time to get going, but once the chase begins (Buster is an engineer whose train is stolen and the film depicts his recovery of it- and the girl, Marion Mack) then it becomes amazing stuff. The stunts, as I've mentioned already, are phenomenal and generate real drama. The gags are constantly funny and inventive. Buster's performance shows an impressive ability to express a range of emotions with very little expression on his famous 'stoneface'- confusion, frustration, anger, happiness, adoration, rejection; all with a movement of one eyebrow. Like Roger Moore only good.

the-general-2

Most importantly, though, the direction- again by Buster- is excellent. The balance between action, comedy and romance is finely judged. The narrative is clear and the choice of camera shots is sublime. 8/10