Saturday, 7 February 2009

A Night at the Opera (1935)

A quick note for my memory because it's late and I'm tired and I'm all giggled out. I've always found the Marx Brothers to be horribly overrated- Groucho is hilarious but Harpo's cute goofball act irritated me and Chico always struck me as superfluous. Admittedly, I'd only seen bits of their movies but they didn't leave me wanting more.

Tonight during the semi-serious musical interlude scene, after Chico's gleeful piano recital, with Harpo sat at the, ahem, harp I suddenly got it. Without my consent and by some devious and insidious double-dealing I realised that I had been and was being entertained. Somewhere, somehow I must have had preconceptions of the Marx Brothers holding me back and they had been shattered. It's funny but that's human nature, no doubt some offhand comment at an impressionable age left its indelible mark upon me- like the scar from a childhood tree-climbing mishap- and I'd had my guard up all of this time. ¡Sono un idiota!

a-night-at-the-opera

Like all great comedy films, this is cleverly paced-out- a breathlessly funny scene like the Groucho/Chico contract negotiation ("That's what they call a sanity clause." "You can't fool me! There ain't no Sanity Claus!") being followed by a the liner boarding scene and Allen Jones and Kitty Carlisle's rendition of the song 'Alone'. It also features some great second-string performances from Margaret Dumont and Sig Ruman.

The gags come in all forms from slapstick to the very subtle, both verbally and visually, some side-splitting and some excruciating but all funny in their own way. I enjoyed it, I really enjoyed it. 6/10.

A quick note for my memory because it's late and I'm tired and I'm all giggled out. I've always found the Marx Brothers to be horribly overrated- Groucho is hilarious but Harpo's cute goofball act irritated me and Chico always struck me as superfluous. Admittedly, I'd only seen bits of their movies but they didn't leave me wanting more.

Tonight during the semi-serious musical interlude scene, after Chico's gleeful piano recital, with Harpo sat at the, ahem, harp I suddenly got it. Without my consent and by some devious and insidious double-dealing I realised that I had been and was being entertained. Somewhere, somehow I must have had preconceptions of the Marx Brothers holding me back and they had been shattered. It's funny but that's human nature, no doubt some offhand comment at an impressionable age left its indelible mark upon me- like the scar from a childhood tree-climbing mishap- and I'd had my guard up all of this time. ¡Sono un idiota!

a-night-at-the-opera

Like all great comedy films, this is cleverly paced-out- a breathlessly funny scene like the Groucho/Chico contract negotiation ("That's what they call a sanity clause." "You can't fool me! There ain't no Sanity Claus!") being followed by a the liner boarding scene and Allen Jones and Kitty Carlisle's rendition of the song 'Alone'. It also features some great second-string performances from Margaret Dumont and Sig Ruman.

The gags come in all forms from slapstick to the very subtle, both verbally and visually, some side-splitting and some excruciating but all funny in their own way. I enjoyed it, I really enjoyed it. 6/10.

Friday, 6 February 2009

Tie Me Up! Tie Me Down! / ¡Átame! (1990)

This, the third Almodóvar film I have seen, is much less intricately-plotted and challenging than either Talk To Her / Hable Con Ella or All About My Mother / Todo Sobre Mi Madre. This is a very simple story of a troubled youth who kidnaps a young actress with the intention that she should get to know him and fall in love with him. The kidnap victim does indeed 'fall in love' with her kidnapper, setting up a happy ending which feels wrong. Whilst she may or may not be suffering from Stockholm Syndrome, the fact remains that for me it is implausible and lends the movie a flimsiness with the inevitable consequence that it cannot endow the gravitas the subject deserves.

The simple narrative- with very little in the way of a back-story or subplots- is used as a vehicle for the exploration of male/female relationships. Throughout the film, female characters refer to independence as onerous and undesirable ("Remember freedom means solitude"; "Are you alone?" "yes, like a dog") and- in the Movie Director's wife- one character displays tolerance of his humiliating and unpleasant behaviour with stoicism and resignation. In contrast, only one male perspective is explored at all (the kidnapper Ricky, played well by Antonio Banderas) and this shows love and being in a relationship as a necessity and something to be achieved at all costs.

As in Talk To Her (where a rape scene is filmed with tenderness) a crime, here a kidnap, is shown as a justifiable and romantic act- which raises moral questions about passion, respect, compatibility and patriarchal dominance for the viewer to take away and consider. This is an extreme situation used to place every day life under the microscope. The imprisonment and subjugation of Marina (Victoria Abril) represents everyday suburban relationships- Marina's sister Lola (Loles León) asks "how can you love someone who ties you up? Do you think that's normal?". The concept of normality is examined throughout- coming from an orphanage and psychiatric institution, Ricky's only ambition is to lead a normal 'wife and 2.4 children' life- but his method of doing so is utterly abnormal. Having been- to some extent- incarcerated from the age of three, does he see the kidnap of Marina as normal, or just a means to achieve a specific end?

This, however, is all an interesting consideration of these issues, rather than the deep exploration that Almodóvar's later works would become. Nicely acted, nicley directed, well paced but slight- 6/10.

Thursday, 5 February 2009

Never Say Never Again (1983)

I can only think that the title is one of the smug selling points the producers made when pitching this bloody awful idea to Connery- "just think how funny it would be Sean! Imagine Roger Moore's face when he sees you're back- that'll raise a few eyebrows. well, one...". That said, nothing should have persuaded him to get back in the toupee for this. Nothing. To coin a phrase- the world is not enough.

I've decided, in my wisdom, to watch all of the Bond's that I'm pretty unfamiliar with and after this and The Man With The Golden Gun I'm beginning to think I should abandon the plan- clearly there's a reason that I'm unfamiliar with them.

Presently I'm just short of an hour and a half in and I've paused it to write a few notes on here as an excuse not to watch any more. When Connery jacked it in because he was too old it was already an overdue decision- he had sleepwalked through the last couple he made- and this was made twelve years after that. There are concessions to that time-gap with Sean having a grey wig and a new stiff upper-lipped bureaucrat boss who has semi-retired him into teaching new recruits but it isn't very convincingly done. Anyway, M (Edward Fox- just how many of these Foxes are there?) sends Bond to convalesce in a Health Farm where he stumbles upon SPECTRE's latest domination plot! And so I'm thinking "this is fucking Thunderball isn't it?" and sitting and gradually growing in fury that they've got Connery in to remake a film he made nearly twenty years earlier, but I resolve to stay calm and give it a chance.

Never Say Never Again / Octopussy - Battle of the Bonds

From memory this was brought out in direct competition with the 'official' release Octopussy. Now the Roger Moore film was embarrassing because of the slapstick humour, the fact that Moore is too old and fat and the all-round low standards of everyone involved. I think this is worse. One of the great things about Bond is it's fantasy- in Octopussy Moore got to fight a seven foot Sikh on the wings of a plane, Never Say Never Again's comparable moment was Connery fighting a bloke from Wolverhampton on the set of Dinnerladies. This is a very watered-down attempt. It isn't low-budget and, as I said recently, I often prefer low-budget movies- the problem is that the vast majority of the budget seems to have been spent on getting Connery in and flying the crew to Barbados, the South of France and wherever else they fancied going. Everything else is done shoddily and with disregard- the interiors are appalling for example. The purpose of the movie appears to be to get people in, irrespective of what they'll tell their friends when they leave. This is not a film that could ever be a word-of-mouth success. Even the dialogue- which is appalling- seems to have been designed with the trailer in mind- like this exchange between Bond and Q (not dear old Desmond Llewellyn, obviously): Q- "Now you're on this, I hope we're going to have some gratuitous sex and violence". Bond- "I shertainly hope sho too". Speaking of Q- who Bond mysteriously keeps calling Algernon- there is a slapstick appearance by rubber-faced so-called comedian Rowan Atkinson as a bumbling bureaucrat called Small-Fawcett- for fuck's sake!- who foresees John Cleese's cringeworthy Q. If this wasn't warning enough, I don't know what would have been.

But this could have worked. The premise, as I said, has real potential and Connery was certainly capable of delivering in the role a wearied, ageing, vulnerable Bond- which he really doesn't do here. I'm thinking of something like McQueen in The Hunter which I watched recently. It isn't a great movie by any means, but McQueen's "I'm getting too old for this shit" performance would have been a great example to follow. Aside from that, you have a magnificent Blofeld in Max von Sydow- bizarrely asked to use a Dutch/Flemish accent and Kim Basinger as a lead Bond girl. Both here, though, are wasted. The attention instead is paid to Klaus Maria Brandauer's appalling Maximilian Largo (a villain as sinister and threatening as a ball of wool) and Barbara Carrera's hilariously bad SPECTRE number 12 Fatima Blush. From water-ski-ing in a thong to throwing a hissy fit when Bond suggests he may have once had better sex with a girl in Philadelphia, she is hardly Rosa Kleb. SPECTRE were clearly hard up for villains after years of good work by Bond. The film also feature's Hit Man's American Football-player turned slab of wood blaxploitation star Bernie Casey as Felix. He is crap obviously.

So the film wastes the opportunities it has and instead focuses upon trying to out-Roger Moore Roger Moore. Bond is variously shot in soft-focus during a saxophone-scored bedroom scene (they didn't even bother covering Sean's tattoo for that one), chased by radio-controlled sharks, plays a video game against the villain Largo and fails to catch a woman in stilettos driving a Renault 5 despite being on a gadget-laden motorbike designed by Q.

I said above that I've paused about three quarters of the way through. I've decided that I'm not watching the rest- 1/10. One mark for simply being a Bond film.

Ed Wood (1994)

The first time I saw this I enjoyed it in the same way that I enjoy watching, say, Plan 9 From Outer Space-style tat- I enjoyed laughing at it rather than with it. This was my second viewing and I didn't enjoy it half as much and by the end I was bored to tears. I'm by no means a Tim Burton fan because of his 'distinctive style' which is a polite euphemism for lack of variety, but he has made some films I've really enjoyed. With this, though, he shows no objectivity whatsoever- more or less everyone is mugging for the cameras as if their lives depended upon it. Perhaps that's the joke- the relatively huge number of continuity errors I spotted would suggest so- but if so, it wasn't quite clever enough to pull it off.

Burton's regular lead Johnny Depp is as irritating as fuck in this, all hyperactive head-shaking and Porky Pig speech patterns, I usually like his hammy style but in this (as in last year's bloody dreadful Sweeney Todd) he was proper tat. In addition Bill Murray- by 1994 almost completely morphed into the 'Buster Keaton without the stunts' that he is today- is miles away from his best form. Add to that a script that gets repetitive and fails to intrigue at all and you're looking at a proper flop. A shame because the film could have been really good with just a little more care and attention.

martin-landau-as-bela

What saves the film is the career-best performance of Martin Landau as Bela Lugosi. He is worth the admission price alone and for that I'm thinking 4/10.

Wednesday, 4 February 2009

Hunger (2008)

The director of this film is usually described as an artist-turned-filmmaker. I must confess that I don't know anything about him, though the name seems familiar somehow, but this film is very much a piece of art. For a directorial debut, this is an astonishingly confident piece- as if McQueen's art background him empowers him somehow and provides the freedom to produce very bold work. That freedom works extremely well.

The film is stark and brutal in its portrayal of the conditions within the Maze prison. It focuses upon the human story and not the political context. As little attention as possible is paid to the rights and wrongs of the prisoners' actions nor the British Government's, they are simply laid out as facts for context. It is possible to view the film as falling into three distinct parts- the first establishes the conditions within the prison, the second is a long scene between Bobby Sands (Michael Fassbender) and a Priest, with the final third charting his decline and death.

McQueen takes an unconventional means of making a 'biopic'. In a film which is ostensibly about hunger striker Bobby Sands, the main character doesn't appear until midway through. The first half of the film is all about establishing what life is like for the prisoners. There are long periods of stillness and silence, a microcosm of the boredom the prisoners endure. The degradation and inhumanity of the prison cells are starkly portrayed and the prisoners' blanket protest (considering themselves political prisoners, they refused to wear prison uniforms and were therefore naked but for a blanket) and long matted beards and hair emblematic of the bodily protests to follow. The cells are so vividly depicted that their stench seems to emanate from the screen. This is realism as a horror film. Terrible visual images of men smearing the walls with their own faeces and living amongst it, the grimy air thick and putrefying, their discarded meal remains eaten by hand and then smeared into the squalid mess already clinging to the walls. These men are brutalised by their conditions and by the guards and brutalise themselves, they regress to the point of animalism- a wordless, often mindless, unclean, base savagery.

The film, in fact, opens by following one of the Prison Guards through his meticulous domestic routine- neatly pressed uniform ready when he dresses, symmetrically laid breakfast table, checking under the car for bombs- into the changing rooms of the prison where the camaraderie of the other guards (presumably of the non-political prisoners) is juxtaposed with his steely solitude and absolute silence. As his hands are washed we see his lacerated knuckles clearly. The clean orderliness is a vivid contrast for what is to follow inside the prison and the officer himself is an integral part of the film's narrative. He appears only twice more. Once when he is part of an army of prison guards who forcibly bathe and cut the hair of the prisoners- this is little more than an opportunity to beat the men and is the source of those lacerations- and again when he visits a retirement home and is assassinated without warning by an unknown assailant. This is fantastic film-making because of the questions it provokes about the morality of both sides and what the viewer would do in those positions. No conclusions are offered, only questions.

hunger

The middle section of the film is stunning. A fixed camera holds Bobby Sands- forcibly cropped and sporting facial injuries- and a Priest (Liam Cunningham) in conversation. Their conversation develops slowly and carefully as though the men were boxers dancing from side to side, measuring the strength of the other. They smoke and discuss and the conversation turns to Sands' plan to lead seventy-odd prisoners on a hunger strike designed to force the British government to recognise their actions as political and not criminal. McQueen is very careful here not to preach a particular message, Sands speaks with sufficient detail and passion to convince of his own dedication without allowing the scene to turn into a soapbox tirade. The Priest and Sands argue at length about the motivation and justification for and repercussions of the action: "you want me to argue about the morality of what I'm about to do? For one, you call it suicide- I call it murder". It is clear to both men that this is a final protest and one which cannot achieve its ostensible aim. This is the only protest, the only significant action, the only act of defiance left open to the prisoners. The scene has gone on for ten minutes or more without a pause, a cut or a change of angle- as with Herzog's Woyzeck (discussed recently) it takes tremendous bravery for a director to pin a film on performances only with no recourse to editing whatsoever and in that vein this scene is a huge gamble but works excellently.

It works excellently right up to the first point that lets the film down. As the conversation draws to a close, Sands tells the Priest an almost certainly apocryphal story from his childhood as an explanation of his motivation. Where the film thus far has been grounded in realism and has had a clear intellectual integrity, there is now a pause whilst a fantastical element is added to offer unsubtle clarity at the expense of plausibility. The story jars horribly with everything that has gone before, undermining it and offering a concession to conventional cinematic expectations which is utterly disappointing.

McQueen uses the final section of the film to investigate in graphically close attention the process of the hunger strike. Fassbender's harrowing acting performance up to this point now becomes a disturbing piece of performance art as we see the starvation process played out upon his body. As Christian Bale did in The Machinist, Fassbender goes to extraordinary lengths of physical suffering, losing stones and weakening himself to the point of exhaustion to depict the dying Sands. His physical condition becomes genuinely sickening and you begin to ask yourself if this is morally acceptable in the name of art. What was an extraordinary performance becomes an unmissable one at this point but, sadly, the film deteriorates. For most of the final sequence the haunting physical decay of Sands is shown in stark silence by McQueen and this echo of of the opening section of the film works fantastically but at the very end- as Sands expires- McQueen begins introducing childhood flashbacks to the piece and some of the melodramatic story which disappointed in the middle third is acted out.

This is such a great disappointment, as if McQueen's courage failed to hold and he had to offer up a more acceptable, time-honoured and less risky conclusion to the film. It also moves the film dangerously away from the perspective of a fascinated but impartial and objective observer to becoming something of a hagiography of Sands. It isn't quite that, but the balance and thought-provoking manner of the opening two thirds certainly stops abruptly. In Sands last days his carer is changed from a medic who appears genuinely compassionate, though not necessarily sympathetic, to a huge muscular man whose first act is to show Sands the UDA tattoo on his knuckles and then to allow him to fall painfully to the floor. This isn't the intelligent and non-partisan approach which made the film so fantastic, it is heavy-handed and manipulative.

It is such a fucking shame. Nine tenths of this film is bold and artistic, it is a genuinely thought-provoking cinematic exploration and the remainder is disappointing, conventional melodrama. 9/10